Skip to content

    Buying

    How does an appraiser value a custom home that has not been built yet?

    November 19, 2026 · By Kenny Agbim · 6 min read


    An appraiser values an unbuilt custom home from its plans and specifications, on a stated hypothetical condition that the home is already finished. What HUD's 90 percent threshold changes, what Fannie Mae accepts as a basis besides a plan set, who confirms the house got built as appraised on Form 1004D or a borrower-and-builder letter, and the four limits on closing before the last of the work is done.


    An appraiser values an unbuilt custom home from its plans and specifications, on a stated assumption that the home is already finished. FHA calls this "subject to completion per plans and specifications on the basis of a hypothetical condition that the improvements have been completed." A second look after construction confirms what was actually built.

    That one sentence carries most of what a custom-build buyer needs to understand about the appraisal, because it explains why the plan set matters so much, and why a change order halfway through the build is not only a budget question.

    What does "subject to completion per plans and specifications" mean?

    It is one of the conditions an appraiser can place on a value. HUD's FHA Single Family Housing Appraisal Report and Data Delivery Guide, issued 20 May 2024 and effective 19 August 2024, lists it among the conditions of the value estimate and applies it in three situations: where the subject is proposed construction and construction has not started; where the subject is under construction but less than 90 percent complete; and where the mortgage is a Standard or Limited 203(k).

    The phrase "hypothetical condition" is doing real work. The appraiser is not valuing a slab, or a framed shell, or a lot. The appraiser is valuing a finished house that does not exist yet, and saying so on the face of the report.

    What construction stage does the appraiser record?

    The same HUD guide instructs the appraiser to mark the stage of construction on the appraisal report as one of three options: "Existing," "Proposed" or "Under Construction." For proposed or under-construction homes, the year built is entered as the current year.

    The guide does not define those three terms, so the classification is the appraiser's judgement applied to the condition of the site on the day of inspection. That date matters: the guide states that the effective date of the appraisal, for FHA purposes, is the date the property was inspected.

    How does the appraisal method change as the house gets built?

    Stage on the day of inspectionHow the value is conditioned
    Proposed, construction not startedSubject to completion per plans and specifications, on a hypothetical condition that the improvements are complete
    Under construction, less than 90 percent completeSame — plans and specifications are the basis
    Under construction, more than 90 percent complete, only minor finish work or buyer preference items remainingSubject to the listed repairs or alterations; HUD's guide says this "eliminates the need for plans and specifications"
    No repairs, alterations or inspection conditions notedAppraised as-is

    The 90 percent line is the one worth remembering. Below it, the plan set is the evidence. Above it, with only items like floor coverings, appliances, fixtures or landscaping left, the house itself has become the evidence.

    What can the appraiser rely on besides the plans?

    Plans are not the only permitted basis. Fannie Mae's Selling Guide section B4-1.2-05, version dated 10 December 2025, states that for new or proposed construction the appraisal must be based on either plans and specifications, an existing model home, or other information sufficient to identify the home's quality and character well enough to accurately report the interior features of the proposed improvements.

    That is why a production builder with a standing model home can be appraised with less paper than a one-off custom design. On a true custom build there is no model to walk, so the plan set and the specification schedule carry the whole burden. An incomplete specification — finishes listed as "allowance TBD," for instance — is a valuation gap, not just an open item on the builder's list.

    Who confirms the home was built the way it was appraised?

    Someone has to go back and check. Fannie Mae's guide states the general rule plainly: improvements, alterations and repairs on the subject property must generally be complete when the loan is sold to Fannie Mae, and verification of completion is required before that sale.

    There are two accepted ways to do it.

    The usual one is Form 1004D, the Appraisal Update and/or Completion Report, completed by the appraiser. The guide permits the appraiser to complete the completion-report section based on an on-site visual inspection, and also allows virtual inspections, digital photos and site videos, with the requirement that all completion documentation include one or more visually verifiable exhibits. A related point from Fannie Mae's section B4-1.2-01, version dated 3 September 2025: interior photographs on proposed or under-construction properties may be taken at the time of the completion inspection and submitted with the 1004D, rather than at the original appraisal, for the obvious reason that there was no interior to photograph.

    The alternative is a letter. Fannie Mae permits a letter confirming the property was completed and constructed in conformity with the plans and specifications, amendments and change orders, signed and dated by both the borrower and the builder, carrying the borrower's name, the property address, certification language, and exterior and interior photos of the property. The guide is specific about the fallback: if a letter signed by both parties cannot be obtained, a Form 1004D completed by the appraiser is required.

    What if something is genuinely not finished at closing?

    Fannie Mae's postponed improvements policy covers that case for new construction, and it has limits attached. The postponed items must be completed within 180 days of the note date. They must be part of the sales contract and must not affect the occupancy permit. The cost of completing them must not exceed 10 percent of the "as completed" appraised value. A completion escrow equal to 120 percent of the estimated cost is required, unless a guaranteed fixed-price contract covers the full amount. Completion is then confirmed by a Form 1004D or an acceptable alternative.

    Those four numbers are the shape of the exception. They are narrow enough that postponed improvements are a tool for a pending fence or a late driveway, not a way to close on a house that is not really done.

    Why does this make a change order an appraisal question?

    Because the document that closes the loop says "in conformity with the plans and specifications, amendments, and change orders." The conformity statement has to reconcile the house that got built with the paperwork the value rested on. A change that is agreed verbally on site and never written into a change order leaves nothing for that statement to point at.

    Practically, on a custom build, that means change orders are worth keeping as a clean, ordered, signed set from the first one. Not because an appraiser will ask for the file in that form, but because the completion documentation is where an undocumented change becomes somebody's problem.

    What does this article not cover?

    This is the process, not advice on a particular loan or property. Appraisal requirements differ by loan type, and a portfolio construction loan, a VA loan or a jumbo lender may set their own conditions over and above the Fannie Mae and FHA requirements described here. The appraiser is selected by the lender, not by the buyer or the builder, and on an FHA appraisal the only permitted signature is that of the lender-selected FHA Roster Appraiser.

    Questions about how a specific contract allocates the cost of an appraisal shortfall, or what a particular change order does to a draw, belong with the lender, the title company, and where the question is legal or tax in nature, with an attorney or a CPA.

    Market figures are sourced as noted and reflect the period described. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

    More from the journal


    Buying · November 20, 2026

    Do you need a certificate of occupancy to close on a new home in Texas?

    Texas has no statewide certificate of occupancy, so the answer is set city by city. Plano's own guide says certificates are not issued for single-family homes. Dallas's development code applies except for single family and duplex uses, yet the city still publishes a $500 early move-in penalty. What a certificate is, which North Texas cities issue one for a house, how a temporary certificate works, and why your lender's completion test is a separate question entirely.

    Buying · November 18, 2026

    What is the new Texas seller's water disclosure, and when do you get it?

    Since 1 July 2026, Paragraph 7I of the TREC resale contract puts water rights on the face of the contract as a single checkbox with three settings. What the paragraph says, what TREC Form 61-0 asks the seller, which box carries a termination right, and the five statements that let a seller skip the disclosure entirely.

    Working through this yourself? The buyer's guide and the seller's guide cover the process end to end, and the communities pages set out each area in detail. Moving in from out of state? Start with relocating to Dallas–Fort Worth.

    Begin

    Have a question about your own move?

    A private, no-pressure consultation — buying or selling, across Dallas–Fort Worth.